[Salon] Polite dishonour




Forwarded this email? Subscribe here for more


The construction of a port for Gaza with the ostensible aim of delivering aid recalls the remark of John F Kennedy about the division of Berlin by a fence and later a wall: that it was a hell of a lot better than a war. That’s because everyone knows this port may be someday used to depopulate Gaza without inconveniencing Israel and Egypt. As Andrew Jackson told the Cherokee: exile is better for you than death. But, no matter what happens, we will have your land.

Thus, a Leitmotiv:

  • Demanding the protection of a civilian population under occupation according to international law whilst providing the arms, funds, and political support for starving and killing them.

  • Demanding the replacement of a prime minister whilst knowing that any likely replacement, and the majority of Israelis, endorse the same means and ends for Gaza and the West Bank as he does.

  • Demanding respect for the territorial integrity of a post-imperial state (Kuwait, Ukraine, etc.) whilst colluding in the redrawing of the borders of another (Serbia, Western Sahara, etc.) by force.

  • Demanding the choice of war by a weaker power against a stronger one whilst insisting that the war isn’t your own by proxy and, at the same time, is backed by the majority of your own people (when it isn’t).

  • Demanding that NATO put ‘boots on the ground’ in Ukraine whilst knowing that most NATO members will never publicly agree to doing that, and knowing that some already have done.

  • Demanding a respect for the democratic process whilst provoking or defending ‘regime change’ (ie exile or death) of unpopular rulers.

And so on.

The impartial observer is moved to ask, isn’t all this hypocrisy in the nature of things? Well yes, it is. So too is what usually follows dishonour, polite or otherwise. Disgrace.

Or worse, as JFK found out. Or, maybe not. Checking out before the bill came due, as someone once said, was a wise career move.



This archive was generated by a fusion of Pipermail (Mailman edition) and MHonArc.